Friday, 21 September 2012

Pakistan film protests: 19 die in Karachi and Peshawar


The BBC's Orla Guerin in Islamabad says police opened fire towards protesters who managed to breach the barricades
At least 19 people have died as violent protests erupted on the streets of Pakistan's main cities in anger at an anti-Islam film made in the US.
Fourteen people were killed in the port city of Karachi and a further five died in the north-western city of Peshawar, hospital officials said.
Protesters clashed with police outside the diplomatic enclave in the capital, Islamabad, near the US embassy.
There has been widespread unrest over the amateur film, Innocence of Muslims.
Dozens of people have been reported wounded and BBC correspondents said some were in a critical condition.

At the scene

Pakistani police fired more tear gas into the dark, trying forcibly to bring protests in Islamabad to an end.
Right in front of me there was a sea of people completely shrouded in tear gas.
Earlier, a volley of live rounds caused many of the thousands of demonstrators to turn on their heels.
However, a hardcore of several hundred kept rushing out, chanting, then piling back in for more tear-gassing.
It was certainly a gamble by the Pakistani government to give the whole country a day-off to protest. The idea was to try to support peaceful demonstrations.
Islamabad was meant to have been sealed, but many protesters still managed to get in.
The focal point once again was the diplomatic quarter in the centre of the capital and the US embassy.
And it was a wider message from the protesters: a lot of the chants were not just against America, but against the Pakistani government.
The crowds called on Islamabad to break ties with Washington.
Protests have already left several people dead around the world, including Pakistan, where the government had appealed in advance for peaceful protests, declaring a holiday and "day of love" for the Prophet Muhammad.
Although US targets have borne the brunt of protests against the film, anti-Western sentiment has been stoked further by caricatures of the Prophet Muhammad published this week in the satirical French magazine, Charlie Hebdo.
France shut embassies and other missions in around 20 countries across the Muslim world on Friday.
Protests were banned in France itself and in Tunisia, where France is the former colonial power, but there were widespread demonstrations elsewhere.
  • A peaceful protest took place outside the US embassy in the Malaysian capital, Kuala Lumpur
  • Some 3,000 people marched in the southern Iraqi city of Basra
  • Thousands burned US and French flags in the Bangladeshi capital, Dhaka
  • Crowds rallied in Baalbek in Lebanon in a protest organised by the Shia militant group, Hezbollah, burning US and Israeli flags
  • Thousands of Libyans joined a march in Benghazi against Islamist militia who have been blamed for an attack in which the US ambassador and three other American officials were killed
Cinemas ransacked
But it was in Pakistan's major cities that protesters took to the streets in big numbers and tried to march on US diplomatic buildings.

Film protests in pictures

Pakistani protester in Islamabad (21 Sept 2012)
US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton said that "all governments have the duty, the solemn duty, to defend diplomatic missions", AFP news agency reported.
The worst of the violence took place in the country's biggest city, Karachi, and the north-western city of Peshawar, close to Pakistan's lawless tribal belt.
Police in Karachi fired live bullets in the air to disperse crowds after a large rally that had begun peacefully turned violent. Several cinemas and banks were set on fire and there were reports of looting.
When police tried to stop the protesters heading to the US consulate, there were reports of gunfire from the crowd and a policeman was killed.
Health officials said the bodies of dead protesters were taken to two hospitals.
In Peshawar, protesters ransacked cinemas and a driver for Pakistan's ARY TV was killed when police opened fire on the crowd.
In the capital, Islamabad, which saw its first clashes between protesters and security forces on Thursday, a police checkpoint was burnt as demonstrators tried to breach the "red zone" where the main embassies and government offices are based.
Police used live rounds and tear gas as the crowd swelled to thousands of people.
The BBC's Aleem Maqbool said the focal point of people's anger was the US embassy and he had seen more people injured in one hour than all of Thursday.
In Lahore, protesters toppled over shipping containers that police had placed on the road to block access to the US consulate.
Phones suspended
The low-budget film that has prompted the unrest was made in the US and is said to insult the Prophet Muhammad.
Its exact origins are unclear and the alleged producer for the trailer of the film, Nakoula Basseley Nakoula, is in hiding.
Anti-US sentiment grew after a trailer for the film dubbed into Arabic was released on YouTube earlier this month.
Video courtesy of the US embassy in Pakistan
US citizens have been urged not to travel to Pakistan and the US embassy has paid for adverts on Pakistani TV showing President Barack Obama and Secretary of State Hillary Clinton condemning the film.
Mobile phone services had been suspended in many of the biggest cities to limit the potential for violence but critics questioned the Pakistani government's decision to declare a public holiday.
Government security adviser Rehman Malik told the BBC that the public holiday was the right decision and the protests would have gone ahead regardless.
"Imagine if I had not done the holiday, school would open, shops would open, the transport was on the road. Who could have handled it?" he said.

Thursday, 20 September 2012

Deadly clash at Peru protest over Barrick gold mine


Map of Peru

Related Stories

One person has been killed and at least four injured in clashes between police and protesters at a gold mine in the northern Ancash region of Peru.
Canadian firm Barrick Gold said it would temporarily suspend production at its Pierina mine following the clash.
The protesters are demanding that the firm provide nearby towns with water.
Pressure group Human Rights Watch has called on Peruvian President Ollanta Humala to stop police from using lethal force against protesters.
At least 19 people have died in disputes over natural resources since President Humala came to office in July 2011, according to figures released by Human Rights Watch.
Human Rights Watch demanded that Mr Humala ban the security forces from using live ammunition at demonstrations and to provide them with other, non-lethal weapons to control crowds.
'Water wars'
The latest clashes erupted on Wednesday when police tried to clear protesters from a road they had blocked leading to the Pierina gold mine near Huaraz.
The protesters from the nearby community of Mareniyoc blame the mining company for a worsening water shortage and demand the firm supply them with drinking water.
Mine official Gonzalo Quijandria said the company had offered residents water from a purification plant, but that their offer had been rejected.
"The community does not want to use water that comes from the mine, even though it's treated and certified," he said.
The protesters told local media they believed the water was contaminated and complained about being ignored by mine officials.
Mr Quijandria said that the issue of water supply was "a problem outside our [the mine's] control".
According to Peru's human rights agency, there are more than 200 disputes over natural resources in Peru, many of them involving access to water and allegations of pollution by mining companies.
The BBC's Mattia Cabitza in Lima says mining is a huge revenue earner for Peru, but that ongoing social and environmental conflicts are threatening to delay billions of dollars of investment.

Pakistani TV shows US ads condemning anti-Islam film


Pakistani TV channels are airing an advert showing news clips of US President Barack Obama condemning an anti-Islam film made in the US.
The advert also features a statement from Secretary of State Hillary Clinton at a news conference rejecting the amateur film's message.
Unrest over the film, Innocence of Muslims, has claimed several lives.
Also on Thursday, a protest against the film outside the US embassy which had turned violent ended peacefully.
The adverts seek to emphasise the message reiterated by US officials throughout the crisis: that the "disgusting" film was not made by the US government, but that there is never any justification for violence.
The embassy described the advert as a "public service announcement" and repeated the statements from Mr Obama and Ms Clinton on itsTwitter feed.
A caption on the advert, which ends with the seal of the US embassy in Islamabad, reads "Paid Content", the Associated Press reports.
State department spokeswoman Victoria Nuland confirmed the US spent $70,000 (£43,220) to air the 30-second clip on seven Pakistani TV stations.
She said the US embassy in Pakistan wanted to run the ads because they determined those messages were not reaching enough of the Pakistani public through regular news reporting.
"As you know, after the video came out, there was concern in lots of bodies politic, including Pakistan, as to whether this represented the views of the US government," Ms Nuland said.
She said the television spots were the "best way" to reach as many as 90 million Pakistanis.
The low-budget film that sparked the controversy was made in the US and is said to insult the Prophet Muhammad.
Its exact origins are unclear and the alleged producer for the trailer of the film, Nakoula Basseley Nakoula, is in hiding.
'Out like a light'
The Pakistani authorities had earlier called on the army as police struggled to contain the crowd of thousands outside the US embassy in Islamabad with tear gas and live rounds.
Some protesters had said they would not leave the diplomatic enclave until the US embassy was on fire.
Streets leading to the enclave, where most of the embassies are housed, were earlier blocked off with shipping containers in an effort to increase security.
Television pictures showed chaotic scenes as police tried to gain control of the situation.
Protesters burned an effigy of President Obama and threw missiles at the police.
The BBC's Aleem Maqbool in Islamabad, who did not see any evidence of the army at the scene, says the protest was "turned out like a light".
He said it was amazing, given the strength of feeling at the protest earlier, that the crowd left as peacefully as it did.
The US state department earlier issued a warning against any non-essential travel to Pakistan.
It also "strongly urged" US citizens in Pakistan to avoid protests and large gatherings.
Anti-US sentiment has been growing since people became aware of the amateur film earlier this month.
The US Ambassador to Libya was killed in an attack on the US consulate in Benghazi on 11 September.
The US secretary of state announced on Thursday that she would appoint an independent panel, chaired by a retired diplomat, to investigate the incident.
White House spokesman Jay Carney said earlier in the day, in a statement read to reporters on Air Force One, that it had been "a terrorist attack".
Protests in countries around the world have since taken place, with tensions further inflamed by the publication by a French magazine of obscene cartoons of the Prophet Muhammad on Wednesday.
The Pakistani government has called a national holiday on Friday to enable people to demonstrate peacefully.
Map showing location US embassy within diplomatic enclave